Midsomer Murders has been a beloved television series for decades, captivating audiences with its picturesque English countryside settings and intricate murder mysteries. A recent ranking of the top 20 episodes has sparked a wave of nostalgia and discussion among fans.
(True fact: as well as being one of my favourite shows, it’s also a big hit with our former podcasting co-host, Brian Terranova…)
While the series has seen a change in its lead detective, from the incomparable John Nettles to the equally charming Neil Dudgeon, the core appeal remains the same: a blend of quirky characters, idyllic villages, and, of course, plenty of murder.
One of the highlights of the series is its diverse range of episodes, from historical thrillers to contemporary mysteries. Episodes like “Midsomer Rhapsody” and “The Sword of Guillaume” (Mark Gatiss appears) offer a unique blend of music and history, while others, such as “The Axeman Cometh” (which features Suzi Quattro) and “The Creeper,” (the actual Rik Mayall, people!) feature memorable guest performances from well-known actors.
(In fact, I regularly ruin episodes for my wife by highlighting who is who. Having said that, she typically asks me why she recognises certain people, so…)
However, even the most ardent fans acknowledge that the series has experienced some fluctuations in quality. Recent episodes, while still enjoyable, have been criticized for their slower pace and lack of energy. Some viewers have suggested that it might be time for a fresh start, perhaps with a new detective to reinvigorate the series.
Despite these minor criticisms, Midsomer Murders remains a beloved TV institution. What is behind its enduring popularity? I suspect it is the show’s ability to provide comfort, escapism, and a healthy dose of mystery. Not all episodes are top-drawer, and I’m not sure I would agree with this list, but that’s what makes these things interesting.
Whether you’re a long-time fan or a newcomer to the series, there’s no denying the charm of a good old-fashioned murder mystery set in the heart of the English countryside.